Most homeschool parents want to do more than just teach math so that their children can pass tests. They want to make math meaningful! Instead of memorization alone, many parents want to help their children develop critical reasoning and problem-solving skills and find ways to apply the study of mathematics to real life. Perhaps most of all, however, many parents want math lessons to form a firm foundation on which later instruction can build. This is the first in our blog series Making Math Meaningful. Please take some time to read what long-time homeschooler Nikki Madison has to say about choosing a math curriculum, and then share your opinions in the comments section:
Choosing a math curriculum may be one of the most difficult parts of planning home education. You may hear about a wonderful curriculum that served your best friend’s family well and find that it only frustrates your child. Sometimes the great curriculum your homeschool support group recommends may even become a source of frustration for you–the homeschool teacher (or supervisor, if you prefer). This is because there is no one-size-fits-all when it comes to math curriculum choices. Instead, the best math curriculum is the one that fits your child’s learning style as well as your unique teaching style as a homeschool parent. If you make this choice a personal one, you are less likely to go wrong.
One very basic thing to consider when you are comparing math curricula is whether the pages will be in black and white or in color. This may not seem to be such a big deal, but it can be a factor in how well your child pays attention to his math lessons. Some children become very distracted by colorful pages that have photographs or cartoon-like illustrations on them. Others may become bored with simple black-and-white pages. You know your child best and can use this knowledge to select curriculum materials that will keep his attention on his math.
You may also consider how new concepts are taught and already-learned concepts are practiced when you are trying to choose the right math curriculum. Some math programs include lessons or chapters that are separated by concept. With such a choice, your child may practice a particular concept or small group of related concepts for the entire lesson or chapter, mastering the new material fully before moving on to the next concept. In such a case, review work may be provided, but the new concept is the focus. With others, most of a lesson, unit, or chapter may be review, and a small amount of instruction and practice may focus on a new concept. The best choice for your child may depend on the amount of repetition she needs (and can stand without becoming bored or frustrated). Some children need a good deal of repetition so that they do not forget key concepts and methods of problem solving. Others find it easier to master a set of concepts fully before moving on to focus on something else.
As the teacher or homeschool supervisor, your satisfaction with the math curriculum you choose is important as well. Before choosing, you may assess whether you prefer a curriculum you can just jump into and start teaching or want one that requires you to review the concepts and lessons before teaching each day. You may also consider whether you want a curriculum that is scripted or not. Some parents prefer scripted lessons because they feel less worried about what to say and making a mistake. Others feel that the scripts sound too, well, “scripted” and prefer to add their own creativity into teaching math lessons. The best curriculum is the one with which you are most comfortable.
There are all sorts of math programs you can choose, so it’s not just about comparing textbook to textbook or
workbook to workbook. You may choose an entirely online curriculum, a textbook/workbook option or a textbook-based curriculum that has an online component. Some materials are centered around math games and activities while others are video based. There are even some curricula that include an audio component for those who learn well by listening.
Sometimes it takes a bit of trial and error to learn what works best for your child, but there’s one way to ensure that the materials you choose are never a total flop: taking a combination approach. Often, attacking math from a number of various angles is the way to go. Doing this may not only help your child to retain the information he’s learning, but may also help to prevent him from becoming bored (a sure killer for true learning). Choosing a curriculum that combines regular bookwork with online or video instruction may prove beneficial. Opting for one that includes math games and hands-on activities, especially those that involve the use of manipulatives, may help as well. Remember, you don’t have to search far and wide for the perfect curriculum. You can supplement a basic math curriculum with other resources to create a math program that is perfect for you and your child.
Ending this blog post without a word about cost just wouldn’t be right. It’s easy to fall into the trap of thinking the most expensive math curriculum is the best, but this is far from the truth. You could find a math curriculum treasure at a second-hand sale, at a bargain price, or even for free in some cases. Sometimes, however, the curriculum you really want is out of your budget range. If this happens, consider buying it used from another homeschooler or bartering for it (if the curriculum company is willing). Otherwise, you may evaluate the components that make this curriculum the best option and use lower-priced math materials to create a similar program.
Nikki Madison is the mother of four homeschooled children and a freelance writer. After an initial year of trying to mold her oldest to fit an award-winning math curriculum, she learned to choose and adjust curriculum materials to suit the needs of her children.